Two popular options for making coffee are the Keurig coffee maker and the French press coffee maker. The Keurig is a single-serve coffee maker that uses pre-packaged coffee pods to brew the coffee, while the French press is a manual coffee maker that uses ground coffee and hot water to brew the coffee.
In this article, we will compare French press vs Keurig and we’ll discuss its pros and cons to help you decide which one is best for you.
Brewing coffee in a Keurig
Keurig is a convenient and easy-to-use coffee maker. To brew coffee in a Keurig, simply insert a coffee pod into the brewer, press a button, and wait for the brewer to brew.
Keurig offers a wide range of coffee pod options, including various blends, roasts, and flavors, making it easy to find a coffee to suit your flavor preferences.
Keurig Advantages over French Press Coffee Maker
- Easy to use: The Keurig is incredibly easy to use, and even those who aren’t coffee experts can easily make a cup of coffee on a Keurig.
- Convenience: The Keurig coffee maker is incredibly convenient, as it takes less than a minute to brew a cup of coffee.
- Variety: The Keurig offers a wide range of coffee pod options, making it easy to find a coffee to suit your flavor preferences.
- Preparation: Prepares coffee in individual portions quickly.
Disadvantages of Keurig Coffee makers
Environmental Impact: Keurig coffee pods are not biodegradable, which means they contribute to environmental waste.
- Cost: The cost of Keurig coffee pods can increase over time, and can be more expensive than the French press.
- Capacity: You cannot prepare large amounts of coffee at the same time
- Taste: Some people may not like the taste of Keurig coffee, as it may be slightly artificial or synthetic.
Brewing Coffee in a French Press
The French press coffee maker is a manual coffee maker that requires a little more effort than the Keurig.
To make coffee in a French press coffee maker, you have to grind the coffee beans, add hot water, and let the coffee brew for a few minutes before pressing the plunger down to separate the coffee grounds from the brewed coffee.
Related: Percolator vs French press coffee maker
Advantages of the French press coffee maker compared to the Keurig
- Taste: French press coffee is generally considered to have better flavor and richer than that from the Keurig coffee maker. As coffee grounds are in contact with water for longer, more oils and flavors are extracted from the coffee.
- Control: The French press allows you to control several factors, such as the water temperature, coffee-to-water ratio, and steeping time, making it easy to customize the coffee to your liking.
- Very affordable: A good French press can be purchased for less than $30
- Capacity: You can prepare 3 to 6 cups at a time depending on the size you choose
- Portable: Perfect for traveling and backpacking
- Environmental impact: French press coffee makers are usually more environmentally friendly, as they do not require disposable coffee pods.
French Press Coffee Pot Cons
- It takes a long time: The French press coffee maker can take longer than the Keurig, as it takes several minutes to steep the coffee and requires more preparation.
- Messy: The French press can be a bit messy, and cleanup can be a pain since you have to get rid of the coffee grounds and clean the plunger and filter.
- Health problems: It can raise cholesterol levels since paper filters are not used in the manufacturing process.
French Press vs Keurig: Summary
| Feature | French Press | Keurig |
| Brewing Method | Steeping grounds in hot water | Keurig machines are not very portable |
| Brew Time | 4-8 minutes | Less than 1 minute |
| Convenience | Requires measuring grounds, boiling water separately | Forcing water through a K-cup pod |
| Variety | Can use any type of ground coffee | Limited to K-cup pod varieties |
| Waste | Reusable filter, no plastic waste | Generates significant plastic waste from pods |
| Batch Size | Makes 3-4 cups at once | Makes 1 cup at a time |
| Strength Control | Can adjust steeping time | Auto-controlled, preset strength |
| Cleanup | Requires disassembling press, cleaning parts | Just discard pod, rinse mug |
| Cost | Affordable, around $20-50 | More expensive, $100-200 range |
| Portability | French press is compact | Keurig machines not very portable |
Keurig vs French Press: Differences in details
Here are the main differences between a French press and a Keurig coffee maker:
1. Ease of use and convenience (Keurig wins)
Keurig coffee makers are known for their convenience and ease of use. With the push of a button, you can have a fresh cup of coffee in less than a minute. Keurig coffeemakers are designed to be easy to use, and most models come with programmable settings that let you customize brew strength, cup size, and temperature.
Plus, Keurig coffeemakers use prepackaged coffee pods, so you don’t have to worry about measuring your coffee or cleaning up messy grounds. This makes Keurig coffee makers a great choice for busy people or those who want a quick and easy cup of coffee in the morning.
On the other hand, French press coffee makers can be a little trickier to use, especially for those who are new to the process. To make coffee in a French press, you need to measure the grounds, boil the water separately, and then manually depress the plunger to filter out the grounds.
Although this process may take a bit more time and effort, many coffee enthusiasts enjoy the hands-on experience and find it a rewarding part of their morning routine.
2. Brew time (Keurig wins)
Keurig coffeemakers are designed to brew coffee quickly, with most models taking less than a minute to produce a hot cup of coffee. This makes Keurig machines a great option for those who are short on time or need a quick morning caffeine fix.
By contrast, French press coffee makers require a bit more time and patience. To brew coffee in a French press coffee maker, you need to let the coffee sit for several minutes before pressing the plunger down. Although the process can be a bit slower, many coffee enthusiasts argue that the extra time is worth the superior taste and quality of the coffee.
Smeg is another renowned coffee maker that you can check out.
3. Flavor and quality of the infusion (the French coffee maker wins)
When it comes to taste and quality, I find that French press coffee makers produce a superior cup of coffee compared to Keurig coffee makers. In my experience, French press coffee makers allow coffee to brew longer, resulting in a richer, more flavorful cup of coffee. Also, since French press coffee makers do not use paper filters, the aroma and flavor compounds in the coffee grounds are not retained, further enhancing the flavor.
On the other hand, I have also used Keurig coffee makers and appreciate how they are designed to produce a consistent cup of coffee every time. Although the coffee may not be as rich or flavorful as French press coffee, I still find it to be a nice, high-quality cup of coffee.
If your coffee is watery, we have a guide to prevent watery coffee.
4. Brew Capacity (Winner: French Press)
If you want to make a large pot to share with friends or family, the French press is the best option. French press coffee makers are available in various sizes, with the largest models able to brew multiple cups of coffee at once.
By contrast, Keurig machines are designed to brew individual cups of coffee, making them the best choice for individual coffee consumers or households that each prefer a different type of coffee.
5. Budget (Winner: French Press)
When it comes to budget, French press coffee makers are the clear winners. French press coffee makers are relatively inexpensive and require no more expense than coffee beans. Conversely, Keurig machines can be more expensive to start with, and the cost of coffee pods can increase over time.
Although there are reusable pods for Keurig coffee makers, they can take longer to use and require more effort to clean. If you are looking for a cheaper option, the best option is a French press coffee maker.
FAQs: Keurig vs French Press coffee maker
What is a French press coffee maker?
A French press is a manual brewing device that uses a plunger to steep coffee grounds in hot water, producing a robust and full-bodied cup of coffee.
What is a Keurig coffee maker?
Keurig is an automatic brewing system that uses pre-packaged coffee pods to quickly brew individual cups of coffee.
What are the main differences between a French press and a Keurig?
The main differences include brewing method (manual vs automated), type of coffee used (ground coffee vs pre-packaged pods), and the resulting flavor and strength of the coffee.
Which one offers better control over the brewing process?
The French press allows for more control as you can adjust variables like water temperature, steeping time, and coffee grind size to suit your preferences.
Which one is easier to use French press or Keurig?
The Keurig is generally considered easier to use since it requires minimal manual effort. You simply insert a pod, press a button, and the machine does the rest.
French press vs Keurig: which one produces a stronger cup of coffee?
The French press tends to produce a stronger cup of coffee due to the longer steeping time, allowing for more extraction of flavors from the coffee grounds.
Are there any maintenance differences between the two?
Yes, a French press requires more maintenance as it needs to be cleaned thoroughly after each use, whereas a Keurig may require cleaning cycles and occasional descaling to prevent buildup.
Which one is more environmentally friendly?
The French press is generally considered more environmentally friendly since it doesn’t require single-use coffee pods, which can contribute to plastic waste.
Can you make other beverages besides coffee with these machines?
With a Keurig, you can make various hot beverages like tea, hot chocolate, and even iced beverages. However, the French press is primarily designed for coffee.
Which one is more cost-effective in the long run Keurig or French press?
The French press is usually more cost-effective in the long run as it doesn’t require purchasing coffee pods. Ground coffee is generally more affordable and can be used repeatedly.
Who invented the French press coffee maker?
The French press was first invented by Henri-Otto Mayer and Jacques-Victor Delforge two Frenchmen in 1852. However, the first patent was obtained by Marcel-Pierre Paquet dit Jolbert in 1924. In 1929 Giulio Moneta and Giulio Moneta in the United States took a patent for the French press coffee maker.
Final Thoughts on the French Press vs Keurig
In my opinion, the decision between a Keurig coffee maker and a French press ultimately comes down to personal preference. If you prioritize convenience and ease of use, then Keurig might be the ideal choice for you.
However, if you are looking for a more pronounced and robust flavor profile and are willing to go the extra mile, the French press coffee maker may be the best option.
Check our list of the best automatic pour-over coffee makers.
